#ReleaseTheList

The ultra-progressive group Demand Justice released a list of 32 potential nominees for the Supreme Court. They want Democrat presidential candidates to adopt this list or to release one of their own. This is what then-candidate Donald J. Trump did in 2016 to good effect.

I agree. Release the list! If the list(s) adopted by any of the Democrat candidates is anything like the Demand Justice list, it will be full of radicals, with little judicial experience, chosen to appease constituent groups.

Professor Josh Blackman provides a convenient grouping on The Volokh Conspiracy.

Academics: Michelle Alexander (Union Theological Seminary),  James Forman, Jr. (Yale), Pamela Karlan (Stanford), M. Elizabeth Magill (Virginia), Melissa Murray (NYU), Bryan Stevenson (NYU), Zephyr Teachout (Fordham), Timothy Wu (Columbia),


Progressive Litigators: Brigitte Amiri (ACLU), Nicole Berner (GC SEIU), Deepak Gupta (Gupta Wessler), Dale Ho (ACLU), Sherrilyn Ifill (NAACP LDF), Shannon Minter (National Center for Lesbian Rights), Nina Perales (MALDEF), Thomas A. Saenz (MALDEF), Cecillia Wang (ACLU),


Current/Former Government Officers: Xavier Becerra (California AG), Sharon Block (one of the three NLRB appointments at issue in Noel Canning), Vanita Gupta (Former Obama DOJ), Lawrence Krasner (Philadelphia DA), Catharine Lhamon (U.S. Commission on Civil Rights), Katie Porter (House of Representatives), Jenny Yang (Former EEOC Chair)


Federal Judges: Richard F. Boulware (D. Nev.), Jane Kelly (8th Circuit), Cornelia Pillard (D.C. Circuit), Carlton Reeves (S.D. Miss.)


State Judges: Mariano-Florentino Cuéllar (California Supreme Court), Anita Earls (North Carolina Supreme Court), Leondra Kruger (California Supreme Court), Goodwin Liu (California Supreme Court)

Let’s look at the sitting judges first. All of the Federal judges were appointed by President Barack Obama. They have between five and nine years of experience and only one of them is on a Circuit Court of Appeals.

Pages: 1 2

Update On NYSRPA V. City Of New York

The Supreme Court released new orders relating to oral arguments in New York State Rifle and Pistol Association v. City of New York.

The motion of the Solicitor General for leave to participate in oral argument as amicus curiae and for divided argument is granted. The motion of Neal Goldfarb for leave to participate in oral argument as amicus curiae and for divided argument is denied.

The Supreme Court usually approves the request of the Solicitor General to participate in oral arguments as amicus curiae and will grant his or her request for divided argument.

As to Mr. Goldfarb, he is the only one of those submitting amicus briefs who requested to participate in the oral argument. From what I can tell, he is something of a gadfly who wants to apply linguistics to the legal interpretation. His brief insists that the Court was wrong in its interpretation of language in DC v. Heller.

Crossing Guard Reinstated To Job; Guns Still Seized

Stephen Nichols has been restored to his job as a crossing guard in Tisbury, Massachusetts. He was removed from his job over an overheard remark that a nosy waitress construed as a threat to the local school. You can read more about the circumstances in this post.

Tisbury PD Chief Mark Saloio maintains Mr. Nichols was never fired. Rather his job was just under “review” according to his statement to the MV Times.

“The town, collectively, has expressed an outpouring of concern about Mr. Nichols, and his employment as a school crossing guard. We as well share those concerns. We wish to make you aware that today, Mr. Nichols was informed that he may return to his crossing guard duties tomorrow morning,” Saloio wrote in an email to The Times. “This return to work was always pending upon a final review that was in process. Throughout this period, Mr. Nichols has retained his position as a crossing guard for the town. However, these reviews are thorough and complete, and neither immediate nor instantaneous.”

Chief Saloio went on to defend the school resource officer whose forays to a buy coffee while on the job were criticized by Mr. Nichols.

While Mr. Nichols has his job back as a school crossing guard, his firearms and license to carry have not been restored to him.

Dan Larkosh, of the Edgartown firm Larkosh and Jackson, represents Nichols, and he was pleased Nichols was reinstated. Nevertheless he intends to file an appeal of the decision by Tisbury Police Chief Mark Saloio to seize guns owned by Nichols, as well as his license to carry.


Saloio declined to comment when approached at the Tisbury Police Station. He later told The Times, “There’s nothing that I can legally discuss about the matter. Period.” The police department has also refused to release the police report from the investigation citing the “personnel” exemption of the public records law.

Supporters of Mr. Nichols started circulating a petition to get him both reinstated and to get his firearms and carry license restored to him. According to the MV Times, it has garnered over 800 signatures as of this morning.

Absent the publicity brought to this case by it going viral, I doubt Mr. Nichols would have his job restored to him. Now let’s hope it helps to restore his means of self-defense.

Research Press And The History Of Long Range Shooting

I stumbled across a very interesting website dedicated to the history of long range target shooting today. It is called Research Press: Firearms, Long Range Target Shooting & Associated History. It comes from the United Kingdom.

A mailing list to which I subscribe had a link to an article on it about the .45-70 Springfield and a 2 mile shot made in 1879.

THE SHOOTER at the heavy bench rest squinted as he aligned his .45-70 Allin-Springfield Model 1873 Army rifle on the distant target. The rifle fore-stock and barrel was cradled in a rest; the butt was supported by his shoulder. The rear sight was flipped up to its full height, so with no stock support for his head, the rifle tester from Springfield Armory worked carefully to align high rear and low muzzle sight on the speck that was the target – a surveyed 2,500 yards distant.


Holding his breath, he squeezed the 7-pound trigger. The rifle fired, and some 15 seconds later, signals from the target indicated that his shot had struck well inside the 6-foot diameter bullseye on a target well over a mile away!

The website has a lot of history dealing with the growth of rifle marksmanship and long range shooting in Great Britain. The growth of it was spurred by a fear in 1859 of a potential invasion of Britain by the French. Volunteer groups promoting marksmanship were raised across the country and eventually were merged with the yeomanry to become the Territorial Army which is the reserve element of the British Army.

Local and regional rifle matches become commonplace and by the end of the decade of the 1860’s Great Britain, with no prior tradition for rifle marksmanship, had thousands of trained riflemen.


Great Volunteer reviews before large crowds of spectators, and sometimes royalty, were held throughout the country where the men demonstrated their skill at drill and skirmishing.


The original arm of the Volunteers was the muzzle loading Enfield rifle. In September 1870 this was replaced by the Snider, a breech loading conversion of the Enfield. The adoption of the Martini-Henry breech loading rifle by the Volunteers was commenced in 1879 but not completed until 1885. The issue of the Lee-Metford magazine rifle was authorised in 1895.

This is just skimming the surface. If you have an interest in the history of organized rifle shooting, I’d suggest taking some time and perusing the site. It will be worth your time.

Life In The Volksrepublik

JayG used to refer to Massachusetts as the Volksrepublik in his old blog Marooned. It was a snarky take on life in a very liberal state with an overbearing government. Volksrepublik derives from the German for People’s Republic which is a term often used by Communist or otherwise authoritarian states.

Though East Germany, officially Deutsche Demokratische Republik or DDR, was merely a “democratic republic” and not a “people’s republic, it did have the Volkshammer, the Volksarmee, and the Volkspolizei. Respectively they were the People’s Chamber legislature, the National People’s Army or their military, and the People’s Police or the national state police. The DDR also had the Staatssicherheitsdienst aka the Stasi. This was the secret police agency meant to repress any dissent. The Stasi encouraged and made extensive use of mass surveillance. This meant neighbor spying on neighbor and children spying on parents all with the purpose of reporting deviations to the secret police.

Bear this history in mind when you hear the story of Stephen Nichols, 84, of Tisbury, Massachusetts. It is a small town on Martha’s Vineyard. Mr. Nichols is a Korean War veteran, a former officer with the Tisbury Police Department, a former court official, a former constable, and now a former school crossing guard.

I say former school crossing guard because a waitress at Linda Jean’s Restaurant in Oak Bluffs overheard his complaints about a school resource officer, misinterpreted them, and then reported him to the Tisbury Police.

As reported by the MV Times on Friday:

Nichols said he was unimpressed with the Tisbury School resource officer’s alleged trips to Xtra Mart to get coffee when children came to school in the morning. While dining at Linda Jean’s a couple of weeks ago, Nichols said he told a friend about this and suggested somebody could “shoot up the school” in that officer’s absence, which he described as “leaving his post.” 

Nichols said the waitress made a complaint to Tisbury Police about what she overheard and on the strength of that, (Tisbury PD Chief Mark) Saloio and another officer relieved Nichols of his crossing guard duties while he was in the midst of performing them and subsequently drove to his home and took away his firearms license and guns. 


“He came up and told me what I said was a felony but he wasn’t going to charge me,” Nichols said of Saloio. 


The confiscated guns were later turned over to Nichols’ son-in-law, Nichols told The Times.


Asked if he was given a letter or any paperwork for the seizure of his license, Nichols said, “No he just told me to hand it over so I took it out of my wallet and handed it to him.”


Nichols said he has been licensed for firearms since 1958.


He said he didn’t receive any paperwork or receipts for the seizure of his guns, either.

The Stasi would be so proud of that anonymous waitress as well as the reaction of the police.

The story goes to note that the both Mark Hanover who owns Linda Jean’s and Andy Marcus who was having coffee with Mr. Nichols assert no threat was made. Mr. Nichols merely thought it irresponsible that the school resource officer would leave his post to get coffee. Only one person construed it as a threat and the police ran with that.

This is a reprehensible situation. You have an elderly widower now left defenseless, children were put at risk pulling the crossing guard in the middle of his shift, and a man’s reputation is sullied based upon an overheard comment that was misunderstood.

The responses of the Tisbury Police Department and the Tisbury Town Administrator were classic bureaucratic evasiveness. They refused to talk about it because it was “a personnel matter.”

Now think about this situation in light of the push for red flag laws. Instances like Mr. Nichols will become more common and with more tragic consequences. In this case you had an elderly man who was not a threat to anyone, who loves kids, and who didn’t even carry outside the home. What if it had been a disturbed person triggered to violence by having his or her firearms removed. They are still on the street, they didn’t get the help they needed, and they are only down one tool out of many with which they can commit a violent attack.

I So Want One Of These!

In the video below, Larry Vickers discusses and shoots the Swedish K Gun. Also known as the Carl Gustav M/45, this submachine gun was used extensively in Vietnam by Special Forces and in the Congo by Swedish UN peacekeepers.

The Swedes objected to the US forces using it in Vietnam and imposed an embargo on their sale. Smith & Wesson made a clone called the Model 76 for use by our military. I had a chance to shoot one of these years ago at a blogger shoot put on by LuckyGunner.com. Let’s put it this way, if I had the extra money and didn’t mind waiting months I’d buy one.

The going price for a transferable K Gun is in the $20,000 range. You can get the S&W Model 76 for much less.

Grassley Tells IRS To Ignore Calls For Russia-NRA Probe

The Democrats on the Senate Finance Committee issued a staff report in September calling on the IRS to investigate the NRA over a trip to Russia. They want the IRS to pull the NRA’s 503(c)(4) tax designation. The Senate Finance Committee minority members even called the NRA a “foreign asset”.

Yesterday, Senate Finance Committee Chairman Chuck Grassley fired back in a letter to IRS Commissioner Charles Rettig. He characterized the Democrats’ efforts to get the IRS to investigate the NRA as “partisan” request. He said that the IRS ” is not a political weapon, and it should not be used as such. “

Sen. Grassley goes on to note:

The Minority report focuses on certain NRA personnel who traveled to Russia in December 2015 for a goodwill trip. After reviewing nearly identical evidence as the Minority staff at great length, it was clear to the Majority staff that nothing in those documents reasonably raises questions about whether the NRA should maintain its tax-exempt status under the tax code. Indeed, rather than present a careful and serious analysis, the Minority staff report offers incendiary conclusions unsupported by paragraphs full of belabored references to behavior that “raises serious” but undefined “concerns.” Even the cover of the Minority staff report deems the NRA a “Russian asset,” while nothing in the text of the actual report ever does more than editorialize to that effect.

He recalls the efforts of Obama Administration to politicize the Internal Revenue Service with some sadness.

Moreover, the IRS should never investigate taxpayers as a result of potential political motives. It is critical for the administration of our tax system that the IRS remain ideologically neutral when it comes to enforcing the tax code, and it is just as critical that taxpayers all throughout the United States know and believe this to be true. This decade has already seen the IRS involved in enough controversy around politically-motived tax enforcement, and the IRS should strive mightily to avoid such episodes in the future. As you are well aware, in May 2013 a scandal engulfed the IRS with its partisan enforcement of applications for tax-exempt status under Sec. 50I(c)(4) of the tax code, as led by Ms. Lois Lerner. Sadly, that scandal may have been precipitated by partisan requests for the IRS to investigate its perceived political opponents. This was a tragic episode in the IRS’ history and it must not happen again.

Grassley goes on to conclude that the IRS does important work. However, he warns that if the IRS is to retain its legitimacy with the American people, it must not “biased against them based on the exercise of their constitutional rights.”

He is right. The only way the IRS can ultimately get compliance with tax laws is voluntary compliance. If it is seen as a punitive tool by the Democrats – or the Republicans – it loses any sort of legitimacy and with that compliance. There are not enough IRS Criminal Investigation Special Agents to compel compliance if the American people as a whole say, “I will not comply.”

Time To Win A Gun Or Two

I haven’t posted the monthly contest round-up from The Weapon Blog for a bit now. My mistake!

Aaron’s round-up this month includes 16 handguns, 13 rifles, and a Benelli Super Black Eagle 3 shotgun. There is some nice stuff in there. The list is below.

Handguns
  • Primary Arms Customized Glock
    Deadline: October 13, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://gleam.io/7Bfo2/glocktober-built-for-carry-giveaway
  • Falkor Defense FG-9 PCC 9mm
    Deadline: October 25, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://gleam.io/7N0Zi/win-a-falkor-defense-fg9-pcc-9mm-pistol
  • Springfield XDS Mod.2
    Deadline: October 25, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.rkguns.com/giveaway-2019-september
  • Freedom Ordnance FX-9
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.clearviewfx9.com/trigger-time-tv
  • FNH FNX-45 Tactical
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://fnamerica.com/giveaway/
  • Ballistic Advantage 10.3″ Blackout AR Pistol
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://ballisticadvantage.com/giveaway
  • CMMG Banshee 300 Mk4 AR-15
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.cheaperthandirt.com/category/contest.do
  • Springfield Armory Hellcat
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/the-armory-life-hellcat-giveaway/
  • Canik TP9 Elite SC
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://www.personaldefenseworld.com/2019/09/canik-tp9-elite-sc-giveaway/
  • Kimber EVO SP CS
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/kimber-carry-package-giveaway/
  • Adams Arms P2 Pistol
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    http://win.tacticalshit.com/ts/boogaloo-bugout-kit-giveaway/
  • Glock 19 Gen 4
    Deadline: November 10, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://moriartiarmaments.com/monthly-giveaway
  • Poly80 Roland Special
    Deadline: November 16, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/polly80-roland-special-giveaway/
  • Walther PPS M2
    Deadline: December 30, 2019
    Added to list: November 11, 2019
    https://gleam.io/R8thc/walther-fall-comfort-carry-giveaway
  • Glock 17
    Deadline: December 30, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://secondamendmentuniversity.com/2019/09/19/glock-17-giveaway-ends-on-2019-12-31/
  • Glock 19 Gen 4
    Deadline: 10,000 Mailing List Subscribers
    Added to list: April 25, 2017
    https://www.facebook.com/537382422969862/photos/a.540151952692909.1073741831.537382422969862/1457936634247765/?type=3&theater
Rifles
  • 50 Beowulf AR Pistol
    Deadline: October 15, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.classicfirearms.com/contest/win-an-alexander-firearms-50-beowulf-ar-pistol/
  • FN Ballista
    Deadline: October 16, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://gleam.io/nquh9/the-big-fn-hunting-giveaway
  • Ruger AR-556
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://grabagun.com/giveaway
  • Aero Precision M4E1
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.aeroprecisionusa.com/monthly-rifle-giveaway
  • Thiessens Guided Hunt & CZ 557
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/thiessens-gear-up-hunting-giveaway/
  • Kimber Hunter Black
    Deadline: November 10, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/on-target-fall-hunting-giveaway/
  • Aero Precision M5
    Deadline: December 1, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/precision-rifle-system-giveaway/
  • CBC Industries CBC3V1 AR-15
    Deadline: 11,000 Facebook Fans
    Added to list: January 17, 2018
    https://www.facebook.com/cbcindustries/photos/a.945555062124183.1073741829.811600472186310/1583023605043989/?type=3&theater
  • Savage MK II BTV
    Deadline: 5,000 Group Members
    Added to list: January 7, 2015
    https://mewe.com/join/pray_hard_shoot_straight
  • Xena-15 GEN4
    Deadline: 100,000 Subscribers
    Added to list: February 18, 2016
    https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=qFY0jhhMw54
  • $100 Pacific Coast Outlet Contest
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: April 9, 2018
    https://www.facebook.com/permalink.php?story_fbid=347929455602091&id=204494296612275
  • Cerakote
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: October 17, 2016
    https://welikeshooting.com/bdl/
  • CVA Muzzleloader
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: January 1, 2015
    http://www.cva.com/CVA-Contest.php
Shotguns
  • Benelli Super Black Eagle 3
    Deadline: October 11, 2019
    Added to list: August 21, 2019
    https://www.impactguns.com/giveaways/
Air Rifles
  • None this month
Ammunition
  • 50 rounds of 9mm and 200 rounds of .223
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: May 5, 2017
    https://ammosubscription.com/news/FREE-AMMO-Yes-we-have-a-FREE-AMMO-Drawing-monthly
  • 2,100 rounds of Federal Cartridge 5.56mm 62gr SC FMJ
    Deadline: 20,000 Facebook Fans
    Added to list: April 25, 2017
    https://www.facebook.com/308ghillies/posts/1322348397859140:0
Knives
  • None this month
Accessories
  • Geissele SSA-E and Bolt Catch Giveaway
    Deadline: October 18, 2019
    Added to list: September 25, 2019
    https://gunnersden.com/best-ar-15-trigger/
  • Enhance Your Rifle Giveaway
    Deadline: October 28, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.ammunitiondepot.com/contest-enhance-your-rifle
  • Barnett Whitetail Hunter Crossbow
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://www.ruralking.com/giveaway-2019-october
  • $2,500 Tru-Spec Gear
    Deadline: October 31, 2019
    Added to list: September 20, 2019
    http://tacticalgear.com/sweeps
  • Tactical Toolbox Giveaway
    Deadline: November 1, 2019
    Added to list: September 23, 2019
    https://gunsandgadgetsdaily.com/tactical-toolbox/
  • Last Days of Summer Giveaway
    Deadline: November 15, 2019
    Added to list: August 22, 2019
    https://gatdaily.com/last-days-of-summer-giveaway/
  • $1,000 Giveaway
    Deadline: December 2, 2019
    Added to list: October 11, 2019
    https://app.viralsweep.com/sweeps/full/aaa28e-57558
  • Concealed Carrry Weekly Podcast Giveaway
    Deadline: Recurring Weekly
    Added to list: July 3, 2019
    https://www.concealedcarry.com/podcastprize/
  • $500 Cheaper Than Dirt Gift Card
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: July 11, 2017
    https://www.cheaperthandirt.com/category/contest.do
  • $500 Gift Card
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: March 6, 2017
    https://app.brandsatisfaction.com/land/2165?front_surveys=2134
  • Solo Stove Campfire
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: March 6, 2017
    https://www.solostove.com/monthly-giveaway/
  • Relentless Tactical Gun Belt
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: August 16, 2016
    https://relentless.leadpages.co/relentless-tactical-belt-giveaway/
  • $100 60X Gift Card
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: August 8, 2016
    http://www.60xcustomstrings.com/giveaway/
Raffles
  • Sinner Mass 10-4 Charity Raffle
    Deadline: 500 Tickets Sold
    Added to list: September 24, 2019
    https://www.sinnermass.com/tenfour/
Training
  • Tactical Training Adventure
    Deadline: 60,000 Contest entries
    Added to list: August 17, 2015
    https://freedomfightersfoundation.org/sweepstakes/
Hunting
  • Hog Hunt
    Deadline: Recurring Monthly
    Added to list: February 15, 2017
    http://www.independenceranch.com/free-hog-hunt

Move Over 80% Lowers!

80% lowers have been around for a while now. In some areas like California if you finish one, you have to apply for a serial number, pay a fee, and then engrave the finished lower.

The term 80% lower or frame comes from a BATFE determination that it isn’t a firearm if it is only 80% finished. Thus, there is no NICS check on an 80% lower or frame and it can be mailed to you. Given it was a determination by BATFE, you know it can be changed at any time.

Here is an alternative.

You say it is only a chunk of 6061-T6 aluminum. Not so fast. According to the manufacturer, it is the 0% billet AR-15 lower receiver. It helps to have your own CNC machine or a Bridgeport milling machine. I guess you could go all Khyber Pass and finish it strictly with hand tools. Both methods are beyond my level of skill so I’m stuck with off-the-shelf lowers from Aero-Precision, Anderson, or Spikes.

The manufacturer, 80% Arms, adds that they are restricting sale to the USA only.

While these weapons are not regulated under ITAR yet, we still don’t want these dangerous things to get into the hands of the wrong people, like Kim Jong-un. Therefore, shipping of 0% lowers is strictly limited to USA only. 

Well played, sirs, well played.

NRA Wins, Ollie Loses On Reimbursements

The National Rifles Association will not have to pay former NRA President Oliver North’s legal bills. That was the ruling today by Justice Joel Cohen in the lawsuit brought by the NRA seeking a declaratory judgement. Col. North had sought indemnification for legal expenses incurred as a result subpoenas in the second Ack-Mac case and the Senate Finance Committee’s request for documents.

From Bloomberg.com:

Justice Joel Cohen said Thursday that the gun rights group isn’t required under its internal rules or state bylaws to indemnify North for expenses he’s incurring as a witness in legal matters triggered by the infighting, including a probe of the NRA’s nonprofit status by New York’s attorney general.


The turmoil began when North alleged that Wayne LaPierre, the organization’s longtime leader and public face, used the NRA to enrich himself, an accusation LaPierre denied. North was accused of trying to overthrow him.


Ruling from the bench, Cohen said the case boiled down to the meaning of a 93-word sentence in the NRA’s bylaws and didn’t hinge on allegations between the parties, including the group’s claim that North acted in bad faith when he began looking into alleged wrongdoing at the organization.


“No sentence should be 93 words long, but once you wade through it, the meaning is clear,” Cohen said. “Colonel North’s reading would require something close to a blank check, and that’s just not what the bylaw says.”

As of this writing, the NY State Courts Electronic Filing system does not have the actual ruling posted.

As might be expected, NRA outside counsel William Brewer III called this a “resounding win” for the NRA. What would be interesting to know is how much Brewer, Attorneys and Counselors billed to handle this case. It would also be interesting to know what the legal bills submitted by Col. North amounted to by comparison.

This case was on the surface about whether Col. North was entitled to indemnification or reimbursements of his legal bills incurred. Below the surface you have a very successful effort to get rid of Chris Cox who was a potential successor to Wayne LaPierre. It also consolidated the hold that Brewer has over LaPierre by damaging those who were independent of Brewer or who opposed him. You see more and more of that coming out as time has passed.